No-Bake Peanut Butter Banana Pie

This gloriously creamy, no-bake peanut butter banana pie lives somewhere between banana pudding, peanut butter pie, and a complete lack of self-control. It's rich enough to make people close their eyes after the first bite, easy enough to make on a Monday, and dangerous enough that you may find yourself hiding a slice behind the leftover meatloaf.

Table of Contents

• 🥰 Is this no-bake peanut butter banana pie recipe for you?
• 🧾 Ingredients you'll need for this no-bake pie
• 📖 Recipe
• 🔪 How to make peanut butter banana pie
• 😱 What can go wrong (and how to fix it)
• 👩‍🍳 FAQs
• 📚 More easy icebox pie recipes
• 💬 Comments

This post may contain affiliate links. If you grab something through them, I earn a small commission-at no extra cost to you-and I appreciate it more than good coffee.

🥰 Is this no-bake peanut butter banana pie recipe for you?

• You need a dessert that looks impressive but requires less effort than finding matching food storage lids.
• Peanut butter and bananas are one of your favorite flavor combinations, and you're not interested in hearing arguments against it.
• You'd like people to assume you spent all afternoon in the kitchen when the truth is far less dramatic.
• You've got a couple of ripe bananas on the counter giving you the side-eye.

🧾 Ingredients you'll need for this no-bake pie

The ingredient list is refreshingly short and free of anything requiring a special trip to three different grocery stores. We're just craving pie, not embarking on a sacred quest in search of obscure ingredients.

• Peanut butter cookie crumbs are necessary because if we're making a peanut butter pie, we might as well commit.
• Butter holds the crust together and keeps it from behaving like a pile of delicious sand.
• Heavy cream whips into clouds of richness that make the filling light instead of brick-like.
• Cream cheese adds tangy flavor and enough structure to keep the pie from sliding across the plate like a runaway carnival ride.
• Creamy peanut butter brings the nutty flavor front and center. Use a commercial brand (and not natural peanut butter with the oil on top) for the smoothest texture.
• Brown sugar adds a hint of caramel flavor that plays nicely with both the peanut butter and bananas.
• Vanilla rounds everything out and makes the filling taste finished instead of flat.
• Bananas add sweetness, flavor, and just enough nostalgia to make you wonder if Elvis was onto something after all. 🍌🥜

Grab the free printable cheat sheet with extra tips, storage instructions, troubleshooting help, and bonus FAQs.

📖 Recipe

🔪 How to make peanut butter banana pie

Making this icebox pie is surprisingly easy for something that tastes like it should have required a handwritten recipe card and a full afternoon in your grandmother's kitchen. Here's how to make it happen.

1. Beat the cream cheese, peanut butter, and brown sugar together until smooth and fluffy. If you taste-test a spoonful at this point, no one could blame you.
2. In a separate bowl, whip the heavy cream and vanilla until stiff peaks form. You're looking for "holds its shape proudly," not "sad dairy puddle" or "almost butter."
3. Gently fold the whipped cream into the peanut butter mixture. Try not to stir the life out of it. We worked hard for all that fluffy goodness.
4. Arrange banana slices in the bottom of the crust like you're laying down a delicious foundation. Spread the peanut butter filling over the top, smooth it out, and refrigerate until firm. This is the hardest step.

😱 What can go wrong (and how to fix it)

🍌 The filling won't set.
The pie probably needs more chilling time. Give it at least 4 hours, but overnight is even better. Patience is annoying, but so is pie soup. The other possibility is you mixed in the whipped cream too vigorously and it broke. In that case? Freeze it solid.

🍌 The whipped cream deflated.
Heavy cream needs to be whipped to stiff peaks before folding it into the filling. If it looks like melted ice cream, it wasn't whipped enough.

🍌 The filling turned lumpy.
Cold cream cheese is usually the culprit. Let it soften on the counter before mixing unless you're in the mood to chase little cream cheese pebbles around the bowl.

🍌 The filling is too dense.
Folding and stirring are not the same thing. Fold gently up and over to keep all that lovely air in the whipped cream where it belongs.

👩‍🍳 FAQs

Have other questions? Ask me in the comments!

📚 More easy icebox pie recipes

If you're the sort of person who believes no-bake desserts are one of humanity's finest achievements, I've got good news. My peanut butter pie is so rich and creamy it ought to come with a warning label and a designated driver. The banana pudding pie tastes like every church potluck, family reunion, and good childhood memory got together and formed a dessert committee.

Feeling adventurous? The Dr Pepper Icebox Pie is proof that Southerners will put absolutely anything into a dessert if given enough time and optimism. And the Oreo icebox pie? That's what happens when a package of cookies achieves its highest calling. None of these recipes require turning on the oven, which is important because we're trying to make pie, not recreate the surface conditions of the sun.

The only thing more dangerous than making this pie is telling people it's in the refrigerator. After that, you're just managing a rapidly escalating situation. One that ends with an empty pie dish.